Back

Former Xbox Veteran Says Canceling The Last of Us Online Was the Right Call, Criticizes Naughty Dog and Sony for Green-lighting It in the First Place

yelzkizi Former Xbox Veteran Says Canceling The Last of Us Online Was the Right Call, Criticizes Naughty Dog and Sony for Green-lighting It in the First Place

Who is Laura Fryer, the former Xbox executive commenting on The Last of Us Online?

Laura Fryer is a well-known figure in the gaming industry, having played a key role during the early years of Xbox. She worked as a producer on major first-party titles and was instrumental in shaping Microsoft’s first-party publishing strategy. With deep experience in AAA game development and platform-level decision-making, Fryer’s opinions on large-scale projects—especially live service titles—carry significant weight.

Her recent comments on The Last of Us Online reflect a broader industry perspective: that large, expensive multiplayer projects can become unsustainable if they are not aligned with a studio’s core strengths or long-term operational capacity.

Why was The Last of Us Online canceled by Naughty Dog?

Naughty Dog officially canceled The Last of Us Online in late 2023 after years of development. The studio stated that continuing the project would have required dedicating resources to long-term live service support, potentially at the expense of future single-player titles.

The core reason was not technical failure, but strategic misalignment. Maintaining a live service game demands continuous updates, player engagement systems, and operational infrastructure—something Naughty Dog was not structured to sustain without major internal changes.

Was The Last of Us Online really 80% complete when it was canceled?

Reports and developer comments suggest that the game was significantly advanced, with some claims indicating it was around 70–80% complete. However, “completion” in game development is complex. A game nearing content completion can still require years of live service planning, backend systems, monetization frameworks, and post-launch pipelines.

This means that even if the core gameplay was nearly finished, the most resource-intensive phase—ongoing support—was still ahead.

Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place
Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place

The Last of Us Online development timeline: how long was it in production?

The multiplayer project began as an extension of The Last of Us Part II, initially planned as a standalone multiplayer mode. Development reportedly started around 2018–2019 and continued for approximately four to five years.

Over time, the project expanded into a full-scale standalone live service title, significantly increasing its scope, budget, and development complexity.

Naughty Dog live service concerns: why supporting an online game is different

Unlike traditional single-player games, live service titles require:

  • Constant content updates
  • Dedicated live operations teams
  • Server infrastructure and maintenance
  • Community management and monetization systems

For a studio like Naughty Dog—known for narrative-driven experiences—this represents a fundamental shift in structure. Supporting a live service game is not a one-time effort; it is an ongoing commitment that can last for years or even decades.

Bungie’s reported influence on The Last of Us Online cancellation

Bungie reportedly evaluated The Last of Us Online and raised concerns about its long-term player retention potential. Bungie, with its experience managing Destiny 2, was uniquely positioned to assess whether the game could sustain a live service ecosystem.

Their feedback is widely believed to have influenced Sony’s decision, highlighting risks in engagement, scalability, and post-launch viability.

Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place
Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place

Sony PlayStation live service strategy and what The Last of Us Online meant for it

Sony Interactive Entertainment has aggressively pursued live service games as part of its long-term strategy, aiming to launch multiple titles in this category.

The Last of Us Online was intended to be a flagship entry in this initiative, leveraging a globally recognized IP. Its cancellation represented a significant setback, raising questions about Sony’s ability to transition its single-player-focused studios into live service developers.

What went wrong with green-lighting The Last of Us Online in the first place?

The decision to green-light the project likely stemmed from:

  • The success of The Last of Us brand
  • Industry trends favoring recurring revenue models
  • Sony’s push into live service markets

However, the miscalculation appears to have been underestimating the operational demands of live service games and overestimating how easily a single-player studio could pivot.

Sunk cost fallacy in game development: why studios cancel games late

The cancellation highlights the concept of sunk cost fallacy—continuing a project due to prior investment rather than future viability.

In AAA development, projects can cost hundreds of millions of dollars. Canceling a nearly complete game is rare but sometimes necessary when long-term projections indicate unsustainable returns or strategic misalignment.

Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place
Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place

Naughty Dog multiplayer “Factions” fans: what the cancellation means

Fans of the original Factions mode from The Last of Us were highly anticipating a modern multiplayer experience.

The cancellation disappointed this community, effectively ending hopes for an expanded multiplayer ecosystem within the franchise—at least in the near term.

Could The Last of Us Online have succeeded as a live service game?

While the IP is strong, success in live service depends on:

  • Long-term engagement systems
  • Competitive differentiation
  • Frequent content updates
  • Monetization balance

Without these elements fully realized, even a high-quality game can fail to retain players. Industry skepticism suggests that success was far from guaranteed.

Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place
Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place

Naughty Dog’s next game plans after The Last of Us Online cancellation

Following the cancellation, Naughty Dog confirmed it would refocus on single-player experiences. The studio is reportedly working on new narrative-driven projects, potentially including a new IP or future entries in existing franchises.

This shift aligns with the studio’s strengths and brand identity.

What Vinit Agarwal said about The Last of Us Online being nearly finished

Vinit Agarwal indicated that the project was close to completion from a content perspective. His comments reinforced the idea that the cancellation was not due to lack of progress, but rather concerns about long-term sustainability.

Single-player vs live service: why Naughty Dog may have chosen to refocus

Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place
Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place

Single-player games offer:

  • Finite development cycles
  • Clear creative direction
  • Lower long-term operational costs

Live service games, by contrast, require indefinite support. For Naughty Dog, continuing to focus on single-player titles allows it to maintain quality and creative control without overextending resources.

Lessons for Sony studios from The Last of Us Online cancellation

Key lessons include:

  • Align projects with studio strengths
  • Evaluate long-term operational demands early
  • Avoid overcommitting to industry trends
  • Use expert consultation (e.g., Bungie) earlier in development

These insights may shape Sony’s future approach to live service development.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

  1. Why was The Last of Us Online canceled?
    It was canceled due to concerns about long-term live service support and resource allocation.
  2. Was the game nearly finished?
    Yes, reports suggest it was largely complete in terms of core gameplay.
  3. Who criticized the project’s approval?
    Former Xbox executive Laura Fryer publicly criticized the decision to green-light it.
  4. Did Bungie influence the cancellation?
    Yes, Bungie reportedly raised concerns about player retention and sustainability.
  5. How long was the game in development?
    Approximately four to five years.
  6. What is a live service game?
    A game designed for ongoing updates, monetization, and long-term player engagement.
  7. Will Naughty Dog make multiplayer games again?
    It is possible, but no confirmed projects are currently announced.
  8. What is sunk cost fallacy in gaming?
    Continuing a project due to prior investment rather than future potential.
  9. What will Naughty Dog focus on next?
    Single-player, narrative-driven games.
  10. Could the game have succeeded?
    It’s uncertain; success would have depended on long-term engagement and support systems.
Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place
Former xbox veteran says canceling the last of us online was the right call, criticizes naughty dog and sony for green-lighting it in the first place

Conclusion

The cancellation of The Last of Us Online reflects a broader shift in how AAA studios approach live service development. Despite years of work and significant progress, the decision underscores the importance of aligning projects with long-term strategy and studio capabilities. Laura Fryer’s criticism highlights a key industry lesson: green-lighting a project without fully accounting for its operational demands can lead to costly course corrections.

Sources and Citations

Recommended

Table of Contents

PixelHair

3D Hair Assets

PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of Nipsey Hussle Braids in Blender
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic Korean Two-Block Fade 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Big Sean braids 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character braided bantu knots with hair strands on both sides of the head 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Pop smoke braids 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair Realistic 3d character curly afro taper 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D Dreads (Heart bun) hairstyle in Blender
PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of lewis hamilton Braids in Blender
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character Cardi B Bow Bun with bangs and stray strands on both sides of the head 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Vintage Bob Afro 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair pre-made The weeknd Dreads 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Omarion full 3D beard in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic male 3d character 3D Buzz Cut 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Braids Bun 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of Big Sean Afro Fade in Blender
PixelHair Realistic 3d character full beard in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair pre-made Drake Braids Fade Taper in Blender using Blender hair particle system
Bantu Knots 001
PixelHair ready-made Omarion dreads Knots 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character Cardi B Bow Tie weave 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Drake full 3D beard in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made full weeknd 3D moustache stubble beard in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair Realistic Dreads 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of XXXtentacion Dreads in Blender
PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of Dreadlocks wrapped in scarf rendered in Blender
PixelHair pre-made Afro Fade Taper in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic male 3d character curly fade with middle parting 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair Realistic 3d character afro fade taper 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of Halle Bailey dreads knots in Blender with hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Jcole dreads 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
PixelHair Realistic 3d character bob mohawk Dreads taper 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made faded waves 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made iconic J.cole dreads 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Lil Baby dreads woven Knots 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character Cardi B bob wig with bangs 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made top woven dreads fade 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made dreads afro 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character curly dreads 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made female 3D Dreads hairstyle in Blender with blender particle system
PixelHair Realistic female 3d character pigtail dreads 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D full big beard stubble with moustache in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character Cardi B red curly bun pigtail with bangs style 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made iconic xxxtentacion black and blonde dreads 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D full stubble beard with in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair pre-made Curly Afro in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Snoop Dogg braids hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Long Dreads Bun 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic male 3d character Afro Sponge Twists Dreads 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made full 3D beard in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair pre-made female 3d character Curly Mohawk Afro in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair Realistic Killmonger from Black Panther Dreads fade 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair pre-made Ken Carson Fade Taper in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made goatee in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made iconic 21 savage dreads 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made dreads pigtail hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic male 3d character fade 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D fade dreads in a bun Hairstyle in Blender
PixelHair ready-made Afro fade 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Neymar Mohawk style fade hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made short 3D beard in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of Big Sean Spiral Braids in Blender with hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of Travis scott braids in Blender
PixelHair pre-made Odel beckham jr Curly Afro Fade Taper in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made pigtail female 3D Dreads hairstyle in Blender with blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character full dreads 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Kobe Inspired Afro 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair pre-made Tyler the Creator Chromatopia Album 3d character Afro in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of Khalid Afro Fade in Blender
PixelHair Realistic female 3d character curly afro 4c ponytail bun hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic 3D Dreadlocks: Realistic Male Locs 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair pre-made Chris Brown inspired curly afro 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character curly puffy 4c big hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D full beard with magic moustache in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made full Chris Brown 3D goatee in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made iconic Lil Yatchy braids 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of Lil uzi vert dreads in Blender
PixelHair ready-made 3D full big beard with in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made full 3D beard in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character Pink Pixie Cut with Micro Fringe 3D Hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic Korean Two-Block Male 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic male 3d character Chris Brown Curly High-Top Fade 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made Scarlxrd dreads hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made short 3D beard in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made 3D hairstyle of Nipsey Hussle Beard in Blender
PixelHair pre-made Chadwick Boseman Mohawk Afro Fade Taper in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair Realistic female 3d character curly afro 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic Yeat-Style Van Dyke Beard 3D in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character curly weave 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made top bun dreads fade 3D hairstyle in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair pre-made Nardo Wick Afro Fade Taper in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair Realistic female 3d character bob afro 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character Sleek Side-Part Bob 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair Realistic Juice 2pac 3d character afro fade taper 4c hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female Blunt Bob 3d hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made top four hanging braids fade 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
PixelHair pre-made weeknd afro hairsty;e in Blender using Blender hair particle system
yelzkizi PixelHair Realistic female 3d character Layered Shag Bob with Wispy Bangs 3D Hair in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made iconic Asap Rocky braids 3D hairstyle in Blender using hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made full 3D goatee beard in Blender using Blender hair particle system
PixelHair ready-made short 3D beard in Blender using Blender hair particle system